We live in a time of deep division. Whether we are discussing religion, morality, politics, workplace events, or even how we run a ministry, the language we use can be divisive and harmful if we are not careful. It can be argued that there have been many moments in history and cultures where this has been the case; however, the difference now is that we have the internet, social media, texting, and recording capabilities that cause our words to echo further and linger longer than ever before. We know that gossip damages relationships and reputations, but today, I would like to discuss some more nuanced forms of gossip that are formally identified in the Catechism of the Catholic Church so that we can be careful to avoid them in emotionally charged situations.

The Eighth Commandment states: “You shall not bear false witness against your neighbor.” This commandment is rooted in the truth, which always finds its source in God. In other words, we ought never to lie about our neighbor. However, just because something is true does not always mean it ought to be stated out loud to others. The Catechism states, “Respect for the reputation of persons forbids every attitude and word likely to cause them unjust injury.” Reputation is not a superficial concern; it is intimately tied to human dignity. Every person is created in the image and likeness of God and possesses an intrinsic value, recognized through honor and respect. To harm someone’s reputation is to attack their social standing, which is a visible sign of their inherent dignity. The fundamental respect for the good name of others is not optional for Christians. It is a moral obligation rooted in the dignity of the human person and the charity we owe our neighbor.

Before getting into the specific ways we can damage a person’s reputation, let’s look at what scripture has to say about our words and how we use them. In Proverbs we read, “Death and life are in the power of the tongue” (Prov 18:21). What we say — or fail to say — can build others up or tear them down. With a single comment, we may restore a reputation or irreparably damage it. Jesus himself said, “I tell you, on the day of judgment people will render an account for every careless word they speak. By your words you will be acquitted, and by your words you will be condemned” (Matt 12:36-37). This is a powerful statement. You and I will have to account for every careless word we speak. That sounds like strong endorsement for holding one’s tongue, especially when there is any doubt.

The Catechism identifies three specific sins by which we can damage another person’s reputation: rash judgment, detraction, and calumny (CCC 2477). Let’s take a look at each of these in more detail.

Rash Judgement

According to the Catechism, rash judgment “assumes as true, without sufficient foundation, the moral fault of a neighbor.” This can be subtle or even unspoken — a passing thought, a raised eyebrow, or a whispered comment. We may hear about someone’s behavior and immediately conclude they acted out of malice or sin. We may even convince ourselves that our suspicion is justified or prudent. However, it reveals a lack of charity and a failure to give others the benefit of the doubt. We ought to remember that we do not necessarily have all the information. We might not be aware of all the circumstances and context, and we likely don’t know the extent to which the person’s conscience has been formed. Our Lord says, “Judge not, that you be not judged” (Matt 7:1). This is not a call to abandon moral truth or to cease recognizing sin, but rather, to avoid presuming guilt when we lack knowledge. We can objectively judge sin without judging the sinner. Rash judgment violates the virtue of justice because it renders a verdict when there has been no trial and you are neither the judge nor the jury. It also undermines charity, which always hopes for the best of others. To avoid rash judgment, we must cultivate humility and self-awareness. When tempted to rash judgment, turn inwardly, examine your own heart, and remember the times and circumstances of your own sins.

Detraction

Detraction is the act of “disclosing another’s faults and failings to persons who did not know them.” As I stated earlier, just because something is true does not necessarily mean that it needs to be expressed out loud to others, especially if it will cause harm to a reputation. Charity demands that the truth be spoken in love – and only when necessary. The truth can be like a weapon when spoken carelessly. For example, sharing a colleague’s past mistake with no constructive purpose constitutes detraction. Detraction is especially dangerous in an age where gossip can spread through group chats, social media posts, or anonymous comments. We may think we are just venting or raising concerns, but unless there is a compelling reason, such as protecting someone from harm, revealing another’s faults is sinful. Detraction harms communities, erodes trust, divides friends, and creates an atmosphere of suspicion. We ought to never speak badly of anyone, even in jest. We ought to examine how we speak about others, particularly those with whom we disagree or whom we find difficult.

Calumny

Calumny is the worst of the three sins against a person’s reputation. Detraction involves telling the truth without charity, but calumny involves lies. Calumny harms the reputation of another “by remarks contrary to the truth… and gives occasion for false judgments concerning them.” It may be an outright false accusation, or a subtle distortion meant to mislead. Either way, calumny is an act of injustice that violates both truth and charity. Calumny can be found in slander, in gossip that distorts, or in attributing evil motives without any basis. In the spiritual life, it is often driven by pride, envy, or resentment. We may feel better about ourselves when we make others look worse. However, Jesus is Truth itself. To follow him requires us to speak the truth in all things. Calumny is a betrayal of Christ and a violation of the Communion of Saints. It drives a wedge between people, damages trust, and spreads spiritual rot within the body of Christ.

The Church calls our attention to the sins of rash judgment, detraction, and calumny to assist us in our pursuit of holiness through careful stewardship of our words. In a world that thrives on sensationalism, drama, and division, we are called to be counter-cultural and to recognize every person as a child of God deserving of respect and love. No doubt, all of us have been guilty of these sins at some point in our lives, if even just in our inexperienced youth. Reflect on the times you have been guilty of rash judgment, detraction, or calumny. How could you have handled the situation in a more just and charitable way? Think of an instance in which you were present where someone’s reputation was being damaged by another person through one of these sins. How could you have defended that person better? Identify where you need to grow in virtue and pray for the grace to guard your tongue, interpret others’ actions with charity, and defend the reputation of others so you can better honor the dignity of every person and live out the commandment to love your neighbor as yourself.

BACK TO LIST